Friday, April 06, 2012

Assignment 6: Ansel Adams and Photography

Ansel Adams is one of the most respected names in photography. During his lifetime he produced hundreds of images that became familiar across the world, as tributes to the epic landscapes of North America. Ansel Adams is most well known for his innovative and brilliant black-and-white photos in landscape photography.
Photographs, for Adams, should be sharp, clear depictions, not blurry abstractions in imitation of paintings. Adams’s photographs attempted at setting out the stall of photography as an art form in its own right, with a unique aesthetic value.
The contributions of Ansel Adams to the world of photography go beyond pretty pictures of landscapes and natural forms. One of Ansel Adams' most famous techniques that resulted in landscape pictures that undeniably displayed the wonders of wilderness is known as the “Zone System”. It is a difficult technique that worked around the limits of the camera lens and the film development process. The Zone System is a way to manipulate the tonality of the images and capture the stark and vivid contrasts in nature that could never by recorded by the camera’s limited capabilities. With Ansel Adams’ technique, shooting a rocky landscape will bring out the shadows of crevices, the brightness of the snowcaps, the vivid blue of the sky and the softness of the clouds. His written technical photography manuals are still regarded as influential and relevant in the modern era.

Here are some well known works of Ansel Adams:
1. The Tetons and the Snake River (1942) - BY Ansel Adams
2. Lower Yosemite Fall - BY Ansel Adams
3. Clearing Storm, Sonoma County Hill - BY Ansel Adams
4. Stream, Sea, Clouds, Rodeo Beach - BY Ansel Adams
5. Winter Sunrise, from Lone Pine - BY Ansel Adams
6. Evening, McDonald Lake, Glacier National Park - BY Ansel Adams

As I mentioned above, Ansel Adams was a strong influence in the world of photography, not just because of the beauty of his landscape pictures and the superiority of his skills but also because of the supremacy of his techniques and the enduring legacy of his images. There are great deals of landscape photographers who see Adams as a mentor, and established their own styles further. From the works of these photographers, you can still see the shadow of Ansel Adams who has influenced landscape photography profoundly and deeply.

The following photographs by different photographers show the influence of Ansel Adams’ work in black and white landscape photography.

1.      Alan Ross – "Gates of the Valley"

 Gates of the Valley - BY Alan Ross


The Tetons and the Snake River (1942) - BY Ansel Adams

The fine photographs of Alan Ross can be experienced as sophisticated black-and-white still lifes or grand landscapes. His work is reminiscent of his teacher, Ansel Adams, yet has a distinct personal style.

This photo especially remind me of the workThe Tetons and the Snake River (1942)” by Ansel Adams. The angle of the clouds, even the feel of the mountains, is somehow resembled. You can say that it is definitely an application of Adams’ “Zoon System”. The shadows of crevices and the softness of the clouds are similarly portrayed as in Adams’ works. However, compared to the master’s work of “The Tetons and the Snake River (1942)”, the “Gates of the Valley” by Alan Ross seems less sophisticated in controlling the tonality of the image. After all, the peacefulness of the valley is just expressed as well as the majesty of the river in Adams’ work.

2.      Bob Kolbrener – "Bridalveil Fall"

Bridalveil Fall - BY Bob Kolbrener


 Lower Yosemite Fall - BY Ansel Adams

Bob Kolbrener was born in St. Louis, Missouri in 1942 and graduated from Washington University in 1963. His passion for fine art black and white photography began in 1968 when he innocently wandered into Best’s Studio (now The Ansel Adams Gallery) in Yosemite National Park. The magnificence of the Ansel Adams original prints was overwhelming, and he has been captivated by photography since.

It can be easily tell that Bob Kolbrener’s photo “Bridalveil Fall” is a reflection of the “Lower Yosemite Fall” by Ansel Adams. Even though the “Bridalveil Fall” is shooting from a similar angle, similar foreground and background, the shadows of mountains or the brightness of the fall water are still built with less of “the stark and vivid contrasts in nature” as is in the “Lower Yosemite Fall”. In Ansel Adams’ “Zone System”, he developed ten zones with Zone 0 as pure black and Zone 9 as pure white. The critical point is the use of camera lens to recognize the Zone and the control of film development time. As inspired by the beauty of Adams’ photo and his technique, Bob Kolbrener learned, and mastered, Adams’ technical aspects: viewpoint, lighting, foreground, and background, as well as the exposure and importance of film development. The “Bridalveil Fall” is a good example.

3.      John Sexton – "Tenaya Lake Clouds"

Tenaya Lake Clouds - BY John Sexton


Evening, McDonald Lake, Glacier National Park - BY Ansel Adams

John Sexton is one of the most widely known contemporary black and white landscape photographers and educators. He was Photographic Assistant to Ansel Adams for many years, and his work, in high demand, demonstrates the technical and artistic expertise that one would expect from such an association.

John Sexton’s work “Tenaya Lake Clouds” may recall us of Ansel Adams works in many ways. From this photograph, we can feel the peacefulness in Adams’ “Evening, McDonald Lake, Glacier National Park”, the brightness of the snowcaps, the vivid blue of the sky and the softness of the clouds in most of Adams’ works. Although his work may remind us of Ansel Adams, John Sexton has a very distinctive feel and is immediately recognizable. The brilliance of John Sexton’s work is no less than Adams. In a way, we can say that he has stepped out of the shadow of his mentor and established a personal style and a worldwide reputation.

4.      Ray McSavaney - "Winter Snowstorm, Yosemite Valley"

Winter Snowstorm, Yosemite Valley - BY Ray McSavaney


Clearing Storm, Sonoma County Hill - BY Ansel Adams

Ray McSavaney, born in Los Angeles studied architecture and design. His interest in photography began around 1970 as a form of documenting backpacking trips in the Sierra Nevada mountain range and intensified in 1972 when he attended his first Ansel Adams Yosemite Workshop.

This “Winter Snowstorm, Yosemite Valley” gives me a similar feeling as is in the “Clearing Storm, Sonoma County Hill” by Ansel Adams. It did portray the brightness of the snow and the softness of the clouds as Adams’ work does. However, the darkness of the sky and brightness of the snow covered ground is not normally Adams’ point of contracts in nature. Ray McSavaney was inspired by Ansel Adams in some level, but developed further and tended to stress his own style after all.

 5.      Patrick Jablonski - "Garrapata Beach"

Garrapata Beach - BY Patrick Jablonski


Clearing Storm, Sonoma County Hill - BY Ansel Adams

Patrick Jablonski is a tremendous example of the contemporary black and white photographers inspired by the western landscape. Patrick has worked with John Sexton, Morley Baer, Ruth Bernhard, and for the Ansel Adams Publishing Rights Trust.

In his photograph “Garrapata Beach”, you can see hints of these technical and visionary influences as he formulates his own interpretations of the natural scene. The mysterious feel he portrayed is similar as in Adams’ “Clearing Storm, Sonoma County Hill”, but more. Also, the softness of clouds is more than any photograph of Adams. Even though the view points of the two photographers are different, the subjects they are portraying are somehow similar. They are both well recognized by their black and white photographs of nature. While Patrick Jablonski is lightly influenced and inspired by Ansel Adams, he is more innovated and emphasized on his own style.

Overall, Ansel Adams loved his subject - “nature” with great passion. The famous landscape pictures taken by Ansel Adams are not just photos of the wilderness; they are iconic images of America. They became powerful tools in preserving the country’s beautiful habitats.


References
Dems, K. (2011, May 18). Famous Photographers: List of the Best Photographers of All Time. Retrieved April 5, 2012, from Bright Hub Inc, http://www.brighthub.com/multimedia/photography/articles/33571.aspx
Markusic, M. (2010, May 17). Ansel Adams and Landscape Photography. Retrieved April 5, 2012, from Bright Hub Inc, http://www.brighthub.com/multimedia/photography/articles/33571.aspx
Black & White Photography. (n.d.). Retrieved April 5, 2012, from The Ansel Adams Gallery, http://www.anseladams.com/category_s/13.htm
Sources of Images
Black & White Photography. (n.d.). Retrieved April 5, 2012, from The Ansel Adams Gallery, http://www.anseladams.com/category_s/13.htm
Original Photographs by Ansel Adams. (n.d.). Retrieved April 5, 2012, from The Ansel Adams Gallery, http://www.anseladams.com/

Saturday, March 17, 2012

Assignment 3 - Press Photography vs. Art Photography

Find two press photographs and two art photographs (provide the names of the authors and sources) and explain:
1.   The main differences and similarities between art and press photography:
Art photography refers to photographs that are created in accordance with the creative vision of the photographer as artist (Fine Art Photography, n.d.). It is done to express the artist's perceptions and emotions and to share them with others. In a way, we can say that art photography stands in contrast to press photography which provides a visual account for news events.

Art Photography:
Ansel Adams - The Tetons and the Snake River (1942), Grand Teton National Park, Wyoming. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Adams_The_Tetons_and_the_Snake_River.jpg
Ansel Adams - The Tetons and the Snake River (1942)
Ansel Adams is one of the most widely recognized fine art photographers of the 20th century, and was an avid promoter of conservation. His primary focus was on photography as art.

In the late 1960s and 1970s, news photographers struck up liaisons with art photography and painting, that’s when press photography and art photography began to overlap. By 1987, pictures that were taken on assignments for magazines and newspapers regularly reappeared - in frames - on the walls of museums and galleries (Fine Art Photography, n.d.). From this point, press photography can also be considered as a form of art, but has stricter standards than general art photography.
Although art photography is created primarily as an expression of the artist’s vision, it has also been important in advancing certain causes. For example, Ansel Adams, as mentioned above, while his primary focus was on photography as art, some of his work raised public awareness of the beauty of the Sierra Nevada and helped to build political support for their protection. In a certain degree, some art photographs work in a similar way as press photos, which is to present the reality and raise awareness of, or form impacts upon the public.
Essentially, the term art photography is used to refer work created with a desire in mind, to articulate an impression, a feeling about, or relationship with the world, but press photography is limited to present facts with accountability, accuracy, and objectivity.
Press photography must follow certain rules, such as the code of ethics; however, generally, art photography is not required to do so. Unlike press photography, art photography does not need to represent reality. Art photograph allows audiences to see the world as though the mind of the photographer, whereas press photograph must present events objectively.

Art Photography:
Michael Dweck – Mermaids
Michael Dweck – Mermaids 105
Michael Dweck – Mermaids 106
As Christopher Sweet introduced: Michael Dweck’s mermaids are lovely and aloof and bare of all raiment but for their beautiful manes and the elemental draperies that surround them. Water, light, and lens converge to capture in modern guise the elusive creature of myth. In Michael Dweck’s vision of the mermaid, he nonetheless exposes an aspect of life that is lived naturally as if uncorrupted, indeed pure; and as audiences, we can as well feel so.
Henri Cartier-Bresson, a godfather of photojournalism, said: “There is nothing in this world that does not have a decisive moment” (Icevska, “Week 10”, n.d.). It is true in both art photography and press photography. However, in press photography, the decisive moment is depending on being in the right place at the right time; while in art photography, the “decisive moment” can, or may be created by photographer by choosing a certain place and a certain time. Michael Dweck’s work - “Mermaids” exactly proved this point.

The followings are examples of Press Photography:
2009, Gareth Copley, 1st prize, Sports Action
2009, Gareth Copley, 1st prize, Sports Action
A ball thrown by Australian Simon Katich sends the bails flying, dismissing England batsman Jonathan Trott during the fifth Ashes cricket test match at The Oval cricket ground in London on 20 August. The Ashes, played every two years between England and Australia, is one of cricket's most celebrated rivalries and dates back to 1882. Over the years, 64 series have been played, with Australia winning 31 and England 28. The 2009 series was won by England.

Michael Appleton
Michael Appleton - New Orleans (2006)
2006, New Orleans On September 4, 2005, nearly a week after New Orleans’ flood defences failed under the impact of Hurricane Katrina, much of the city remained underwater and deserted. To add insult to injury, fires continued to burn as a result of gas leaks, fallen power lines and in some cases, arson.
 
2.   Is it ethical and acceptable to alter art photographs? Why? Why not?
Generally, in art photography, photographers are free to pursue artistic expressions. As I mentioned above, unlike press photography, art photography does not need to represent reality. Art photograph allows audiences to see the world as though the mind of the photographer, but press photograph must present events objectively.
Photo manipulation is one of the most creative art forms to come out of the digital age. A typical example would be Photoshop, which is a powerful tool and is used by talented artists and photographers to make great images with high artistic merit. Many art photographs are altered, but they do not purport themselves to be reflections of reality, so there is no ethical issues involved.

The followings are examples of art photography that blending real photos with synthetic elements for a surreal result:
Karol Kolodzinski is a freelance graphic designer who specializes in new media design. His style has earned him some big name clients such as Coca Cola, Ikea, and more.
by Karol Kolodzinski

by Karol Kolodzinski
by Karol Kolodzinski

3.   Is it ethical and acceptable to alter press photographs? Why? Why not? 
Despite the fact that art photography allows manipulation and digital alteration, for press photography, it is another matter entirely. Mostly, it is considered unethical and unacceptable to alter press photographs, but depending on the level of alteration. If a retouching of a press photograph is limited to basic exposure and color correction, cropping, resizing, or conversion to grayscale which make the photograph clearer or more attractive without changing its original meaning, it might be considered as acceptable; on the other hand, any retouching that alters the meaning of the original photo is definitely unacceptable. Most of the media agree that the only acceptable changes are those used to improve the quality of the photograph, but without changing the context/facts on the photograph in any sense (Icevska, “Week 9”, n.d.).
There is a growing body of writings devoted to the ethical use of digital editing in press photography. For example, the National Press Photographers Association (NPPA) has set out a Code of Ethics promoting the accuracy of published images, advising that "Editing should maintain the integrity of the photographic images' content and context. Do not manipulate images or add or alter sound in any way that can mislead viewers or misrepresent subjects." Infringements of the Code are taken very seriously, especially regarding digital alteration of published photographs. In my opinion, press photography is also a kind of documentary photography, so that an altered press photo is a document whose accuracy cannot be verified.

Despite of the codes of ethics, many photographers have been selling their images to the news media, claiming that they have created documentary photography.
Here is a recent example:
According to the article Donald R. Winslow (2012) published at 2012 News Photographer Magazine, the Sacramento Bee has suspended a veteran, award-winning photojournalist over a front page photograph that they say he manipulated, and the newspaper has launched an investigation into the incident.
Bryan Patrick - Original 1
Bryan Patrick - Original 2
Bryan Patrick - Published
"While the original photo did show that same snowy egret grabbing for the frog from the great egret, the photographer merged in a different image of the great egret, in which the frog was more visible. As a result, the published photo included duplicated images of the plants."

Changing the fact in the images is unethical and not acceptable in press photography. The Code of Ethics followed by the most mainstream news media around the globe are very strict and do not allow any changes that might have an impact on the photo composition (Icevska, “Week 11”, n.d.). The audience has the right to know the truth if the photograph is presented as press photography to the public.


 
References
Definition of Fine Art Photography. (n.d.). Retrieved March 16, 2012, from Photography Art Cafe, http://www.photography-art-cafe.com/definition-of-fine-art-photography.html

Fine Art Photography. (n.d.). In Wikipedia. Retrieved March 16, 2012, from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fine-art_photography
Icevska, G. (n.d.). Course Notes Week 9. Retrieved March 16, 2012, from http://sites.google.com/site/shootingthetruth/Home/modules/week-9/course-notes-week-9

Icevska, G. (n.d.). Week 10 - Capturing the moment: Kertesz and Cartier-Bresson. Retrieved March 16, 2012, from http://sites.google.com/site/shootingthetruth/Home/modules/week-10/course-notes-week-10
Icevska, G. (n.d.). Course Notes Week 11. Retrieved March 17, 2012, from http://sites.google.com/site/shootingthetruth/Home/modules/week-11/course-notes-week-11
NPPA Code of Ethics. (n.d.). Retrieved March 16, 2012, from The National Press Photographers Association http://www.nppa.org/professional_development/business_practices/ethics.html
Winslow, D. R. (2012, February 2). Accused Of Digitally Altering Photo, Sacramento Bee Suspends Veteran Photographer. Retrieved March 17, 2012, from http://www.nppa.org/news_and_events/news/2012/02/sacramento.html